If you've ever wondered why one feed with 12% protein seems to do more for your horse than another with 14%, the answer is often the limiting amino acid. It's one of the most useful ideas in horse nutrition, and it explains why lysine, threonine and methionine get so much attention.
The limiting amino acid, explained
To build a protein, the body needs every amino acid in that protein to be available at the same time. If one essential amino acid runs short, protein building slows to the pace of that one nutrient, no matter how much of the others is available. That scarce nutrient is the "limiting" amino acid.
A common way to picture it is a barrel made of wooden staves of different heights. The barrel can only hold water up to the height of its shortest stave. Adding more of the other amino acids won't help until the shortest one is raised.
Researchers at the University of Kentucky describe what happens to the leftovers: if one amino acid such as lysine is deficient, the body converts the excess of the others into carbon dioxide and urea, which are exhaled and excreted (University of Kentucky Equine Programs). In other words, they're wasted.
Lysine: the first limiting amino acid
Lysine is considered the first limiting amino acid in horses, meaning it's the one most likely to fall short in a typical diet (Kentucky Equine Research). Grasses and cereal grains tend to be low in lysine, which is why it's the amino acid most often listed on feed tags (Iowa State University Extension).
It's also the only amino acid with an established requirement for horses in the National Research Council's Nutrient Requirements of Horses (2007). Extension guidance suggests lysine should be at or above about 4% of total crude protein intake, especially for growing horses (Cooperative Extension).
Threonine: likely second
Research suggests threonine is likely the second limiting amino acid for growing horses, especially in grass-based feeding programs (Kentucky Equine Research). Threonine is used in muscle protein and is also important to the protective mucus lining of the gut.
Lysine and threonine together were the supplement used in a well-known study on muscle in mature horses. Horses aged around 9 and around 22 received 20 g of lysine and 15 g of threonine a day for 14 weeks with light exercise. At the end, their muscle mass scores were higher than those of unsupplemented horses, regardless of age (Graham-Thiers & Kronfeld, 2005).
Methionine: a likely third, and a hoof and coat builder
Based on other species, methionine may be the third limiting amino acid in horses (Kentucky Equine Research), although the evidence in horses is mixed. Methionine is one of the sulfur-containing amino acids. Sulfur bonds are what make keratin, the protein in hoof horn and hair, strong, which is why methionine is common in hoof and coat formulas.
What this means for your horse's diet
- Look past crude protein. Crude protein tells you how much nitrogen is in a feed, not whether its amino acids are balanced. Check the lysine figure on the tag.
- Know your forage. Mature grass hay is often lower in protein and lysine. Alfalfa is higher. A hay analysis takes the guesswork out.
- Don't just add more protein. Overfeeding protein to make up for poor quality wastes money, and the excess nitrogen leaves as urea, which adds ammonia to the stall.
- Balance the whole profile. Fixing lysine can make the next amino acid the limiting one. A complete essential amino acid source helps cover the next "shortest staves" as well.
How Vital Amino Blend is built around this idea
Each 5 g scoop of Vital Amino Blend provides 835 mg of L-lysine HCl, 490 mg of L-threonine and 345 mg of L-methionine, together with leucine, isoleucine, valine, phenylalanine, histidine and tryptophan. That's all nine essential amino acids in one scoop, so you're supporting the whole profile rather than a single amino acid. It's made in the USA with no fillers, sugar or soy, and a 600 g tub lasts 120 days.
A small daily scoop is meant to complement a good diet, not replace forage or a balanced feed. If your horse has a medical condition, talk to your veterinarian or an equine nutritionist about its total protein and amino acid intake.
Sources
- Kentucky Equine Research. How Much Protein Does My Horse Need? Amino Acid Considerations for Horses.
- Kentucky Equine Research. Growing Horses: Energy, Protein, and Amino Acid Requirements.
- Iowa State University Extension and Outreach. Protein and the Horse's Diet.
- Cooperative Extension (eXtension) Horses. Nutrient Requirements for Horses.
- University of Kentucky Equine Programs. Horse Lysine Requirements Focus of New Study.
- Graham-Thiers PM, Kronfeld DS. Amino acid supplementation improves muscle mass in aged and young horses. J Anim Sci. 2005;83(12):2783–2788.
- National Research Council. Nutrient Requirements of Horses, 6th Revised Edition (2007).
This article is for general education and isn't veterinary advice. These statements have not been evaluated by the FDA. Vital Amino Blend is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.